Michelle and I had to make a late-night run to the pumpkin patch last night to pick up some pumpkins for the super-top-secret jack-o-lantern project (which I’m sure you’ll hear about soon if you haven’t already, as JesusH reanimates from its extended slumber), and we decided to hit Vons on the way and cash in the penny jar.

You see, the thing had finally gotten full enough that it was getting tough to add additional pennies, and it was becoming a bear to transport, as I was reminded of during our recent move. I used to be able to lift the thing fairly easily with one hand. By the time we cashed in, I didn’t dare even try that due to the significant risk of breakage or strained forearm.


A woman with money is a beautiful thing.

One of the interesting things about getting older is that I notice the amazing age of some of my stuff. Take the penny jar. This thing has been in my possession for almost half of my life… it’s the very jar I initially acquired to keep Marco the fish in, which you were caught up on earlier this year.

I’ve owned the jar for 15 years. I’ve owned the jar since George Bush Sr was President. Hell, it’s older than most of the trick-or-treaters that came by for candy tonight. (Oh, and a very Happy Halloween to you.)

Anyway, after the fish died, I used a punch to connect the air holes in the lid together to make a coin slot and started dropping my pennies in it, and that’s where most of my pennies have been going ever since. I was pretty careful to only drop pennies in the thing–the silver change all goes in the plaster pig bank from Tijuana, so I can’t be tempted to grab a handful and do something stupid with it. Not even in my most fiscally irresponsible times have I ever been tempted to bother taking a handful of pennies out of the pepper jar and blowing them on something (like I might have if I had quarters in there), so the buildup has been slow and steady over the years.

But all good things come to an end, and last night the CoinMaster at Vons got 15 minutes of good exercise processing this mass of copper. Now the mostly empty jar is back on the counter, ready to bulk up again over the next 15 years on a steady diet of the most useless coin in American circulation.

Misc notes on the process:

  • I was indeed careful about not putting anything but pennies in the jar. Four dimes–otherwise, nothing but pennies.
  • the machine rejected about 30 pennies. Most of them turned out to be wheat pennies, which is kind of cool. I had a couple of 1935, more 1936, a bunch of 1937, and two steel 1943 pennies (both of which were so beat up and corroded it’s hard to tell they aren’t copper). We were able to fill holes in some of my mom’s old penny coin folders with a few of them, and the rest are worth about a cent each so they’re going to be the basis of the next penny conglomeration.

    Pop went through the jar fairly recently searching for good stuff; I’m guessing he got anything worth taking already.

  • no foreign pennies were in the reject bin, which I found quite surprising. Either the CoinMaster accepts Canadian currency or I was even better keeping Canadian pennies out of the jar than I was dimes, which I doubt.
  • CoinMaster kept 8.9% for themselves, which is a total fucking ripoff. Luckily for them, I wasn’t enjoying the prospect of moving the full penny jar around any more than I already had and my laziness made me defacto captive audience to their pricing scheme. If you’re going to do anything like this, Coinstar gives full value for your change in gift cards at some locations. I was an idiot for not finding one of these.

Now–who wants to guess how many pennies were in the jar?

8 Comments

  1. I’ve been thinking about getting rid of all my change too. I can’t handle the 9% service charge so I need to hit up one of the CoinStars near my house. I always keep wheat pennies so I hope to have the same luck you did with the rejections.

    Based on the size of the jar and Michelle’s smile, I’m going to guess $96.12.

  2. The 9% service charge is only a bad deal when there is the gift card option available as an alternative. Otherwise, I’m positive it costs me more than $0.09 of my time to roll 100 pennies. I will, and do, roll quarters. When I find a convenient Amazon.com Coinstar I’ll no longer roll quarters.

    Where you’re really getting ripped off is that the melt value of a pre 1983 penny is more than $0.02. And when they retire the penny, which they inevitably will, you may be able to get a significant fraction of the melt value.

    Through a careful process of counting and estimating based on the height of a penny and the diameter of the jar, I’m going with $96.13.

  3. When I find a convenient Amazon.com Coinstar I’ll no longer roll quarters.

    Dre, you’re a busy guy–let me help you with that.

    The melting link is interesting. However, by the time the old pennies are retired I’ll be making five figures an hour, so it won’t be worth my time to pursue.

    Keep those guesses coming, everyone! Whoever is closest will win a prize.

  4. I’m a little partial to rolling coins due to nastalia. My granda would throw her change in a jar and every summer I use to roll the coins for her. As a bonus, she let me keep the money. I completely agree that rolling pennies is a waste resources in a pure valuation of time and money. But it’s a little relaxing and it gives me a chance to pull out coins I want to keep.

    Through a re-evaluation of the jar size, the initial post, and the comments, I’m going to guess that Dre is being a jerk by employing the Price Is Right strategy.

  5. it’s free to have the machine count it at nfcu mission valley. but then again, some of us are too busy WORKING than to worry about pre-melt value differential fractals. stay sucka free.

  6. Those were some underwhelming guesses. Nobody wins the prize.

    5,107 pennies were cashed in.

  7. Damn. That was going to be my second guess.

  8. You know what they say about your first instinct… it’s usually bunkum.

    Also, assuming half old pennies and half new pennies, Google tells me that was about 31 lb of pennies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>